If you’ve ever dreamed of making pasta sauce that tastes like it came straight from an Italian nonna’s kitchen, the Amish Paste tomato might just be your new garden favorite. Known for its meaty flesh, low seed count, and sweet-yet-tangy flavor, this heirloom variety bridges the gap between gardeners and pasta lovers. In this article, we’ll explore the history, growing tips, and culinary magic of Amish Paste tomato plants, showing you exactly why they’re a must-have for both your backyard and your pasta pot. Whether you’re a seasoned gardener or a first-time grower, these tomatoes are worth the soil space.
A Heirloom Tomato with Deep Roots
When I first discovered the Amish Paste tomato, I was wandering through a Pennsylvania farmer’s market on a summer road trip. The vendor, an older gentleman in a straw hat, sliced one open for me to taste. The flesh was thick, the seeds few, and the flavor? It exploded with a balance of sweet and tangy, like the perfect note in a symphony. This heirloom variety has been around since the 1870s, passed down through Amish families for generations.
Unlike Roma tomatoes, Amish Paste tomatoes grow larger, with a more robust, complex taste that holds up beautifully in sauces and slow-cooked dishes. In my kitchen back in Bologna, they quickly became my secret ingredient for a rich, velvety pasta sauce. Today, Amish Paste tomatoes are loved across the U.S. for their versatility in both gardening and cooking. Pair them with the right pasta, find your match in our Best Pasta for Tomato Sauce guide, and you’ll understand why this variety has stood the test of time.
Why Gardeners & Cooks Love I
Gardeners adore Amish Paste tomato plants because they produce consistently large, plum-shaped fruits with a deep red hue that almost glows in the sun. These tomatoes average 8–12 ounces each and have a dense, meaty texture that makes them perfect for canning or cooking down into a thick, hearty sauce. The low seed content means less straining and more tomato in every bite. For cooks, their naturally sweet flavor eliminates the need for extra sugar in pasta sauce recipes, letting the tomato’s own richness shine through.
Whether you roast them for depth, simmer them for hours, or use them fresh in a quick summer pasta, Amish Paste tomatoes deliver. They’re more than just a crop, they’re the heart of a sauce that tastes like summer preserved in a jar.
Print
Amish Paste Tomato Plants: 7 Thrilling Tips for Rich Sauce
- Total Time: 1 hour 15 minutes
- Yield: 6 servings 1x
- Diet: Vegetarian
Description
Rich, sweet, and meaty, this Amish Paste Tomato Pasta Sauce uses freshly harvested heirloom tomatoes for a thick, flavorful sauce perfect for coating your favorite pasta.
Ingredients
3 lbs Amish Paste tomatoes, ripe
2 tbsp olive oil
1 medium onion, finely chopped
3 garlic cloves, minced
1 tsp sea salt
1/2 tsp black pepper
1/4 cup fresh basil, chopped
1/4 cup red wine (optional)
Instructions
1. Blanch the Amish Paste tomatoes in boiling water for 30 seconds, then transfer to ice water.
2. Peel the skins and roughly chop the tomatoes.
3. In a large pot, heat olive oil over medium heat.
4. Add onion and sauté until translucent, about 5 minutes.
5. Add garlic and cook for 1 minute until fragrant.
6. Stir in chopped tomatoes, salt, and pepper.
7. Simmer uncovered for 45–60 minutes, stirring occasionally.
8. Add basil and red wine in the final 10 minutes of cooking.
9. Adjust seasoning to taste and serve over pasta.
Notes
For a smoother sauce, blend with an immersion blender before adding basil.
Freeze extra sauce in airtight containers for up to 6 months.
- Prep Time: 15 minutes
- Cook Time: 1 hour
- Category: Sauce
- Method: Stovetop
- Cuisine: Italian
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 1 cup
- Calories: 120
- Sugar: 8g
- Sodium: 350mg
- Fat: 6g
- Saturated Fat: 1g
- Unsaturated Fat: 4g
- Trans Fat: 0g
- Carbohydrates: 15g
- Fiber: 4g
- Protein: 3g
- Cholesterol: 0mg
Keywords: Amish Paste tomato plants, tomato pasta sauce, heirloom paste tomatoes
Planting & Climate Needs
Growing Amish Paste tomato plants starts with knowing where and when to plant them. These heirloom paste tomatoes thrive in USDA zones 3–9, making them suitable for most U.S. gardeners. They need full sun, at least 6–8 hours daily, and prefer well-draining, loamy soil enriched with compost or aged manure. If you live in the northern U.S., start seeds indoors in late winter and transplant them after the last frost. In warmer southern states, you can sow them directly outdoors once soil temperatures reach 60°F. Expect about 80–85 days from transplant to maturity, so plan your planting calendar accordingly.
For more inspiration on how to work fresh produce into your kitchen creations, browse our Gardening Tips section, where you’ll also find ideas for pairing homegrown ingredients with pasta recipes. A well-prepared garden bed gives Amish Paste tomato plants the strong foundation they need to deliver abundant, flavorful harvests.
Watering & Fertilizing for Maximum Yield
These plants reward consistent care. Water deeply once or twice a week, soaking the root zone instead of lightly sprinkling the surface. This encourages strong root growth and helps prevent blossom-end rot, a common tomato problem. Use mulch to conserve moisture, keep soil temperature stable, and reduce weed growth. For fertilization, start with a nitrogen-rich feed early in the season to support leafy growth, then switch to a phosphorus- and potassium-rich formula when flowers appear to boost fruit production.
Some gardeners swear by companion planting, basil, marigolds, and onions help deter pests naturally. If you’re planning to use your harvest in a pasta dish, think ahead: certain pasta shapes, like those in our Ditalini Pasta feature, pair beautifully with Amish Paste tomato sauces. With the right care, each plant can yield a surprisingly generous crop, giving you plenty for fresh eating, canning, and sauce-making.
Indeterminate Growth , Why Support Matters
Amish Paste tomato plants are indeterminate, meaning they keep growing and producing fruit until frost. Without proper support, these vigorous vines can sprawl across the ground, making them more vulnerable to pests and disease. A sturdy trellis, cage, or stake keeps the plants upright, improves airflow, and allows more sunlight to reach the leaves.
This results in healthier plants and better yields. For gardeners aiming to maximize their harvest, supporting Amish Paste tomato plants is non-negotiable. You’ll notice that fruits grow cleaner and ripen more evenly when the vines are off the soil. Plus, picking is easier, no more hunting through tangled foliage. In my own garden, I’ve found that training Amish Paste tomato plants to a vertical support makes them more productive and keeps the fruit in perfect condition for sauce-making.
Pruning & Pest Control
To get the most from your Amish Paste tomato plants, pruning is essential. Remove suckers, the small shoots that form between the main stem and branches, to channel the plant’s energy into fruit production. This also improves airflow, which helps prevent fungal diseases. Keep an eye out for common tomato pests like aphids, hornworms, and whiteflies.
Hand-pick large pests, use insecticidal soap for small infestations, and consider planting marigolds nearby as a natural deterrent. Mulching with straw or shredded leaves can further protect your Amish Paste tomato plants by keeping the soil evenly moist and reducing splash-back that spreads disease. Healthy plants mean better-tasting tomatoes, and for cooks, that translates to richer, more flavorful sauces.
Whether you’re simmering them into a rustic Sunday ragù or blending them for a silky marinara, every effort you make in the garden pays off in the kitchen.
Picking at Peak Flavor
The joy of growing Amish Paste tomato plants is in harvesting them at the exact moment they’re at their best. Look for a deep, even red color and a slight softness when gently squeezed. Because Amish Paste tomato plants are indeterminate, you’ll enjoy a steady supply throughout the season rather than a single large harvest. For the sweetest, juiciest flavor, pick your tomatoes early in the morning when the fruit is cool.
If they’re slightly under-ripe, you can leave them to finish ripening indoors on a sunny windowsill. Avoid refrigerating unless they’re fully ripe and you need to slow spoilage, cold temperatures can dull the flavor and alter the texture. For longer storage, freezing or canning preserves that sweet-tangy goodness for winter pasta nights.
I’ve found that a batch of summer-harvested Amish Paste tomatoes can transform the simplest pasta dish into something extraordinary, just like our Pistachio Pesto Pasta recipe does in its own unique way.
From Garden to Pasta Pot
One of the biggest rewards of growing Amish Paste tomato plants is turning your harvest into a sauce that outshines anything store-bought. Start by scoring the tomato skins, blanching them briefly, and peeling them for a smoother sauce. Sauté onions and garlic in olive oil, add chopped tomatoes, and simmer slowly to concentrate their natural sweetness. No extra sugar is needed, the Amish Paste tomato plants’ fruit is naturally balanced. For a richer flavor, add fresh basil and a splash of red wine near the end. This fresh sauce pairs beautifully with hearty pasta shapes, and if you’re short on time, you can even adapt it into a one-pan recipe inspired by our Meghan Markle’s One Pot Pasta.
With their dense, meaty texture and few seeds, these tomatoes are tailor-made for sauce, thick enough to cling to pasta and flavorful enough to be the star of the dish. From soil to simmering pot, Amish Paste tomato plants deliver a harvest worth savoring.
Conclusion
From their Amish heritage to their prized role in pasta sauces, Amish Paste tomato plants bring something special to both the garden and the kitchen. They’re vigorous growers, generous producers, and unmatched in the richness they add to homemade sauces. With the right planting, care, and harvesting techniques, you can enjoy a steady supply of sweet, meaty tomatoes all season long. Whether you simmer them into a slow-cooked ragù or turn them into a quick weeknight pasta, these heirloom beauties prove that the journey from soil to table can be as rewarding as the final bite.
Growing Amish Paste tomato plants isn’t just gardening, it’s cultivating a taste of tradition.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Amish Paste tomatoes need a trellis?
Yes. Amish Paste tomato plants are indeterminate, meaning they grow tall and keep producing fruit until frost. A trellis, cage, or stake keeps the plants upright, improves airflow, and helps prevent disease.
How tall does an Amish Paste tomato grow?
With good care, Amish Paste tomato plants can reach 6–8 feet tall, especially in warm climates with a long growing season.
Is Amish Paste a determinate or indeterminate tomato?
Amish Paste tomato plants are indeterminate, producing fruit continuously throughout the growing season rather than all at once.
How to care for Amish Paste tomato plants?
Provide full sun, rich well-draining soil, regular deep watering, and a sturdy support system. Prune for better airflow and monitor for pests.
Are Amish Paste tomatoes the same as Roma?
No. While both are paste-type tomatoes, Amish Paste tomatoes are larger, juicier, and have a richer, more complex flavor than Roma tomatoes.
Can Amish Paste tomatoes be grown in containers?
Yes, but use a large container (at least 5 gallons) and provide strong support for the vines.
How many tomatoes will one Amish Paste plant produce?
Under ideal conditions, one Amish Paste tomato plant can yield 20–50 pounds of fruit in a season.